Baghdad Alamo
This morning, I watched the confirmation hearing for LTG Petraeus, who will be taking over the command of ground forces in Iraq. Although the plan to secure Baghdad is not as new and original as it has been presented, there will be a change in tactics that threatens to increase casualties because more American soldiers will be in exposed positions. Petraeus said to secure Baghdad’s population, “forces must locate with and live with that population.”
In practice, the plan will create 27 high visibility “Joint Security Stations,” essentially small isolated positions in Baghdad neighborhoods that will be permanently occupied. One has just been set up in a cluster of fortified houses in the middle of Ghazaliya, a flashpoint for clashes between Sunni and Shiite gunmen. It’s garrisoned by C Company, 2d Battalion, 12th Cavalry. The Americans stuck there are already calling it The Alamo.
“I’m a juicy target they [the insurgents] are just trying to figure out,†said Capt. Erik Peterson, 29, the commander at the outpost.
During the week, the soldiers also received their first glimpse of the green Iraqi forces who will share the mission and eventually, they hoped, take it over. The soldiers talked about them with a mixture of bemusement, disdain and mistrust.
“You could talk about partnership, but you would be lying,†said one soldier who asked that his name not be used, for fear of punishment by his superiors.
The idea is pacification in place, or a lockdown starting with the Sunni areas of western Baghdad. The new operation will be difficult, according to an analysis by Robert Pelton on IraqSlogger, “since the insurgents can simply go dark, patiently waiting for the operation to end.” If insurgents attack the small fortified outposts, our forces can call in air strikes and artillery fire– with results already seen in places like Fallujah.
General Petraeus gave the Senate Armed Services Committee an honest assessment of what’s coming:
“The situation in Iraq is dire. The stakes are high. There are no easy choices. The way ahead will be very hard.”
If Petraeus is successful, then America will be trying to keep a lid on the Iraqi civil war (at least in Baghdad and its suburbs). How long can we do this? The Pentagon says the cost of occupying Iraq will soon reach $8.4 billion a month. Eventually our soldiers will go, and the Iraqis will resume fighting right where they left off.
Richard Warnick




January 23rd, 2007 at 4:17 pm
Richard,
Nice analysis. As I have said many times over, we will remain in Iraq until the insurgents pull a Lebanon-style attack where 200-plus soldiers are killed in one fell swoop. We will leave Iraq shortly thereafter; notwithstanding, however, all the “oorahs” from our patriots in arms over at ASP and elsewhere.
January 23rd, 2007 at 4:37 pm
It kind of looks like we’re daring the bad guys to try and wipe out one of these outposts, doesn’t it?
January 23rd, 2007 at 5:28 pm
Your kidding right? 27 Joint Security Stations? You mean 27 in EACH neighborhood right?
January 23rd, 2007 at 5:38 pm
Ok, now we are no longer moving targets, but fixed known positions, great. Sort of a modern day Maginot, but on a small scale. Probably easy to defend. I expect to see heavier weaponry in use, by the enemy.
January 23rd, 2007 at 10:02 pm
click on: http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=5f8d5d16c5
for a fine example of amerikan style democracy in action.
Warning: this involves homo torture by egyptian police and is not pretty.
if you have a strong stomach go to: http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=e007f16fb7
for some george bush/alberto gonzales democracy.
February 6th, 2007 at 3:53 pm
[...] The Bush administration’s plan for the continued occupation of Iraq is based on the disproven assumption that American military force can bring security to Baghdad and the Iraqi provinces. That’s why it’s already a failure in the early stages. [...]
April 26th, 2007 at 6:24 am
[...] Events have overtaken every planning effort. There is no unity of command in Baghdad between the U.S. and the Iraqis, or even within the Iraqi government. LTG Petraeus has a brilliant group of staff officers trying to plan a counterinsurgency in the middle of a civil war. So far, all they can think of is to establish dozens of isolated outposts, mini-Alamos for insurgents to attack. [...]